Bill Type
Short Title
JUDICIARY INDEPENDENCE ENHANCING ACT
Text as Filed (File)
Third Reading Copy link (HRep)
Scope
Legislative Status
Legislative Status Date
Session Sequence No.
22
Session Type
Subjects
Document Certification
Bill Transmittal
Conference committee requested by HOUSE (1/27/2016)
All Information (Senate Website)
Legislative History (Senate Website)
Committee Referral (Senate Website)
Floor Activity (Senate Website)
Committee Details
House Committee Report link
Floor Activity
Floor Activity
Date Parliamentary status Senator(s) 2/3/2016 Sponsorship Speech on the Conference Committee Report Pimentel, Aquilino Koko III L.
Legislative History
| House Bill/Resolution NO. HB06040 | |
| FULL TITLE : AN ACT BANNING THE REAPPOINTMENT OF A REGULAR MEMBER OF THE JUDICIAL AND BAR COUNCIL WHO HAS ALREADY SERVED THE FULL TERM | |
| SHORT TITLE : Banning The Reappointment Of A Regular Member Of The Judicial And Bar Council Who Has Already Served The Full Term | |
| ALIAS NAME : Judiciary Independence Enhancing Act | |
| PRINCIPAL AUTHOR/S : ABAYA, FRANCIS GERALD A., YAP, SUSAN A., ESCUDERO, EVELINA G. | |
| DATE FILED : 2015-08-24 | |
| SIGNIFICANCE: NATIONAL | |
| NATURE : Reform | |
| CO-AUTHORS : | |
| 1. Tupas | 2. Hernandez |
| 3. Reyes | 4. Rodriguez (O.) |
| 5. Bello (S.) | 6. Aliping |
| 7. Nava (P.) | 8. Romualdo |
| 9. Noel | |
| COUNTERPART HOUSE BILL/CONCURRENT RESOLUTION: SB02419 | |
| ACTIONS TAKEN BY THE COMMITTEE | |
| COMMITTEE REPORT NO. 00838 | |
| SUBMITTED ON 2015-08-24 | |
| SUBMITTED BY: JUSTICE | |
| RECOMMENDATIONS: approval | |
| SUBSTITUTED BILLS: HB00138, HB01637, HB02038 | |
| ACTIONS TAKEN BY THE COMMITTEE ON RULES | |
| REFERRAL TO THE COMMITTEE ON RULES ON 2015-08-25 | |
| DATE INCLUDED IN OB: 2015-08-25 | |
| DATE CALENDARED : 2015-09-01 | |
| SECOND READING INFORMATION | |
| PERIOD OF SPONSORSHIP : 2015-09-01 | |
| SPONSORED BY : Abaya | |
| DATE APPROVED ON SECOND READING : 2015-09-01 | |
| THIRD READING INFORMATION | |
| DATE COPY DISTRIBUTED TO MEMBERS: 2015-09-02 | |
| DATE APPROVED BY THE HOUSE ON THIRD READING :2015-09-09 | |
| HOUSE VOTES: YEAS:171 NAYS:0 ABSTAIN:.0 | |
| Voting Details Per Member(Legend:Y-Yes N-No A-Abstain X-Did Not Vote B-Absent D-N/A) | |
| Y---Abad | B---Abaya--(Absent) |
| Y---Abayon | Y---Abellanosa |
| Y---Abu | Y---Abueg |
| Y---Acedillo | Y---Acharon |
| Y---Acop | X---Acosta-Alba |
| Y---Adiong | Y---Advincula |
| B---Agarao--(Absent) | Y---Aggabao |
| Y---Aglipay | Y---Agyao |
| Y---Albano | X---Alcala |
| Y---Alejano | Y---Aliping |
| B---Almario--(Absent) | B---Almonte--(Absent) |
| B---Alvarez (F.)--(Absent) | Y---Alvarez (M.) |
| X---Amante | Y---Amatong (I.) |
| X---Amatong (R.) | B---Andaya--(Absent) |
| Y---Angara-Castillo | B---Angping--(Absent) |
| B---Antonino-Nadres--(Absent) | X---Antonio |
| Y---Apostol | B---Aragones--(Absent) |
| B---Arbison--(Absent) | Y---Arenas |
| X---Arnaiz | Y---Arroyo |
| Y---Asilo | Y---Atienza |
| Y---Aumentado | B---Bag-ao--(Absent) |
| Y---Bagatsing | Y---Baguilat |
| Y---Balindong | Y---Banal |
| Y---Barcelona-Reyes | X---Barzaga |
| Y---Bataoil | Y---Batocabe |
| B---Bautista--(Absent) | Y---Bello (S.) |
| D---Bello (W.)--(N/A) | B---Belmonte (F.)--(Absent) |
| Y---Belmonte (J.) | Y---Belmonte (V.) |
| Y---Benitez | Y---Bernos |
| Y---Biazon | X---Bichara |
| Y---Binay | B---Biron--(Absent) |
| Y---Bondoc | B---Bonoan--(Absent) |
| Y---Bravo (A.) | X---Bravo (M.) |
| X---Briones | X---Bulut-Begtang |
| B---Cabilao--(Absent) | X---Cagas |
| Y---Calalay | X---Calixto-Rubiano |
| Y---Caminero | Y---Cari |
| Y---Castelo | Y---Castro |
| Y---Catamco | B---Cayetano--(Absent) |
| Y---Celeste | B---Cerafica--(Absent) |
| Y---Chipeco | Y---Co |
| D---Cojuangco (E.)--(N/A) | B---Cojuangco (K.)--(Absent) |
| Y---Collantes | Y---Colmenares |
| Y---Cortuna | Y---Cosalan |
| X---Cruz-Gonzales | X---Cua |
| Y---Cueva | Y---Dalog |
| B---Dayanghirang--(Absent) | Y---De Jesus |
| X---Dela Cruz | Y---De Venecia |
| Y---Defensor | Y---Del Mar |
| B---Del Rosario (A.G.)--(Absent) | X---Del Rosario (A.A.) |
| X---Deloso-Montalla | B---Dimaporo (A.)--(Absent) |
| X---Dimaporo (I.) | Y---Duavit |
| B---Durano--(Absent) | Y---Dy |
| B---Echiverri--(Absent) | Y---Cerilles |
| Y---Enverga | Y---Erice |
| B---Eriguel--(Absent) | Y---Ermita-Buhain |
| Y---Escudero | B---Espina--(Absent) |
| X---Estrella | Y---Evardone |
| Y---Fariñas | Y---Fernandez |
| B---Ferrer (J.)--(Absent) | Y---Ferrer (L.) |
| Y---Ferriol | B---Flores--(Absent) |
| B---Fortun--(Absent) | Y---Fortuno |
| Y---Fuentebella | B---Garay--(Absent) |
| X---Garcia (E.) | Y---Garcia (G.) |
| B---Garcia-Albano--(Absent) | X---Garin (O.) |
| X---Garin (S.) | B---Gatchalian (S.)--(Absent) |
| B---Gatchalian (W.)--(Absent) | Y---Geron |
| B---Go (A.C.)--(Absent) | B---Go (A.F.)--(Absent) |
| X---Gomez | Y---Gonzales |
| Y---Gonzalez | Y---Gorriceta |
| Y---Guanlao | Y---Guiao |
| X---Gullas | Y---Gunigundo |
| Y---Gutierrez | B---Hagedorn--(Absent) |
| B---Haresco--(Absent) | B---Hataman-Salliman--(Absent) |
| Y---Hernandez | Y---Hicap |
| Y---Hofer | Y---Ilagan |
| Y---Iway | B---Jalosjos--(Absent) |
| B---Javier--(Absent) | B---Katoh--(Absent) |
| Y---Kho | Y---Khonghun |
| X---Labadlabad | Y---Lacson-Noel |
| X---Lagdameo (A.) | Y---Lagdameo (M.) |
| B---Lagman--(Absent) | Y---Lanete |
| Y---Leachon | X---Ledesma |
| Y---Lee | X---Leonardia |
| X---Leonen-Pizarro | Y---Lobregat |
| X---Loong | Y---Lopez (C.) |
| B---Lopez (C.J.)--(Absent) | Y---Loyola |
| B---Macapagal-Arroyo--(Absent) | Y---Madrona |
| Y---Magsaysay | B---Manalo--(Absent) |
| B---Mangudadatu--(Absent) | B---Marcos--(Absent) |
| Y---Masongsong | B---Matugas--(Absent) |
| Y---Mellana | Y---Mendoza (J.) |
| B---Mendoza (M.)--(Absent) | X---Mendoza (R.) |
| Y---Mercado | X---Mirasol |
| Y---Montejo | X---Nava (J.) |
| Y---Nava (P.) | Y---Noel |
| Y---Nograles | Y---Macrohon-Nuño |
| X---Oaminal | Y---Ocampo |
| Y---Olivarez | Y---Ong |
| B---Ortega (F.)--(Absent) | Y---Ortega (V.) |
| B---Pacquiao--(Absent) | Y---Padilla |
| Y---Paduano | Y---Paez |
| Y---Pagdilao | Y---Pancho |
| X---Panganiban | X---Panotes |
| B---Pernes--(Absent) | X---Piamonte |
| B---Pichay--(Absent) | Y---Plaza |
| X---Ponce Enrile | Y---Primicias-Agabas |
| Y---Puno | Y---Quimbo |
| X---Quisumbing | X---Radaza |
| Y---Ramos | Y---Relampagos |
| Y---Revilla | Y---Mercado-Revilla |
| Y---Reyes | Y---Ridon |
| X---Rivera | Y---Robes |
| Y---Gerona-Robredo | Y---Rodriguez (I.) |
| Y---Rodriguez (M.) | Y---Rodriguez (O.) |
| Y---Rodriguez (R.) | Y---Roman |
| B---Romarate--(Absent) | B---Romualdez--(Absent) |
| B---Romualdo--(Absent) | Y---Romulo |
| Y---Roque | Y---Sacdalan |
| B---Sahali--(Absent) | X---Sakaluran |
| Y---Salimbangon | Y---Salvacion |
| Y---Paquiz | Y---Santiago |
| Y---Sarmiento (C.) | X---Sarmiento (M.) |
| Y---Ramirez-Sato | B---Sema--(Absent) |
| Y---Señeres | Y---Singson (E.) |
| B---Singson (R.)--(Absent) | Y---Suansing |
| B---Suarez--(Absent) | Y---Sy-Alvarado |
| Y---Tambunting | Y---Tan (A.) |
| Y---Tan (M.) | B---Tejada--(Absent) |
| Y---Teodoro | Y---Teves |
| Y---Tiangco | Y---Tieng |
| Y---Ting | Y---Tinio |
| X---Tolentino | Y---Treñas |
| Y---Tugna | Y---Tupas |
| X---Turabin-Hataman | X---Ty |
| X---Umali (C.) | Y---Umali (R.) |
| Y---Unabia | Y---Ungab |
| B---Uy (J.)--(Absent) | Y---Uy (R.) |
| B---Vargas--(Absent) | B---Vargas-Alfonso--(Absent) |
| X---Velarde | D---Velasco, L.A.--(N/A) |
| Y---Velasco, L. | Y---Villanueva |
| Y---Villar | X---Villarica |
| X---Violago | X---Yap (A.) |
| Y---Yap (S.) | Y---Yu |
| B---Zamora (M.)--(Absent) | Y---Zamora (R.) |
| Y---Zarate | X---Zubiri |
| DATE TRANSMITTED TO THE SENATE: 2015-09-14 | |
| ACTIONS TAKEN BY THE SENATE/HOUSE | |
| DATE RECEIVED BY THE SENATE: 2015-09-14 | |
| CONFERENCE COMMITTEE INFORMATION | |
| DATE REQUESTED TO FORM A CONFERENCE COMMITTEE : 2015-09-21 | |
| CONFERENCE COMMITTEEE REQUESTED BY : HOUSE | |
| DATE AGREED TO FORM A CONFERENCE COMMITTEE : 2016-01-27 | |
| REMARKS : | |
| CONCOM MEMBERS(HOUSE) : Tupas, Abaya, Escudero, Yap (S.), Bello (S.) | |
| CONCOM MEMBERS(SENATE) : Pimentel, Angara (E.), Ejercito (J.) | |
| DATE HOUSE RATIFIED CONCOM REPORT : 2016-05-23 | |
| DATE SENATE APPROVED CONCOM REPORT : 2016-02-03 | |
| ACTIONS TAKEN BY THE PRESIDENT | |
| DATE TRANSMITTED TO THE PRESIDENT : 2016-06-20 | |
| DATE ACTED UPON BY THE PRESIDENT : 2016-07-20 | |
| PRESIDENTIAL ACTION:(A)PPROVED/(V)ETOED/(L)APSED : V |
Senate Legislative History
Entitled: AN ACT BANNING THE REAPPOINTMENT OF A REGULAR MEMBER OF THE JUDICIAL AND BAR COUNCIL WHO HAS ALREADY SERVED THE FULL TERM [ THIRD REGULAR SESSION, 16TH CONGRESS ] [ 2015 ] Introduced by Representatives FRANCIS GERALD A. ABAYA, SUSAN A. YAP, EVELINA G. ESCUDERO, NIEL JR. C. TUPAS, FERDINAND L. HERNANDEZ, et. al.; Approved on Third Reading by the House of Representatives on September 9, 2015; 9/9/2015 Sent to the Senate requesting for concurrence; 9/15/2015 Read on First Reading and Referred to the Committee on RULES; 9/29/2015 House of Representatives requested the Senate for a conference on the disagreeing provisions of HBN-6040 and SBN-2419, designating Representatives Tupas Jr., Abaya, Escudero, Yap and Bello III as its conferees to the Bicameral Conference Committee on September 21, 2015; [ 2016 ] 2/1/2016 Senate agreed to the request of the House of Representatives for a Conference on the disagreeing provisions of HBN-6040 and SBN-2419, designating Senators Pimentel, Angara and Ejercito as its conferees to the Bicameral Conference Committee on January 27, 2016; 2/3/2016 Conference Committee Report on the disagreeing provisions of SBN-2419 and HBN-6040, submitted to the Senate, recommending that SBN-2419 in consolidation with HBN-6040, be approved as reconciled; 2/3/2016 Sponsorship speech on the Conference Committee Report of Senator AQUILINO KOKO III L. PIMENTEL; 2/3/2016 Conference Committee Report Approved by the Senate; (Transmittal letter sent to the House of Representatives on February 10, 2016); 5/23/2016 Conference Committee Report Approved by the House of Representatives; 6/13/2016 Enrolled copies of the consolidated version of SBN-2419 and HBN-6040, sent to the House of Representatives for the signature of the Speaker and the Secretary General; 6/21/2016 Enrolled copies of the consolidated version of SBN-2419 and HBN-6040, received by the Senate which were signed by the Speaker and the Secretary General of the House of Representatives; 6/30/2016 Pursuant to the provisions of Article VI, Sec. 27 (1) of the 1987 Constitution, the President of the Philippines, President Rodrigo R. Duterte, returned the consolidated enrolled bill SBN-2419/HBN-6040, without his signature on July 20, 2016; 6/30/2016 VETOED BY THE PRESIDENT OF THE PHILIPPINES. (Pursuant to paragraph g, Sec. 7, Rule V of the Rules of the Senate, Vetoed Enrolled Bill (SBN-2419/HBN-6040) with pertinent documents, transmitted to the Archives for safekeeping and preservation on August 3, 2016) (The legislative history/plenary deliberations is prepared by the INDEXING, MONITORING AND LIS SECTION, LEGISLATIVE BILLS AND INDEX SERVICE; The data entry re conducted committee meetings/hearings, conducted technical working group, is prepared by the Committee concerned/Committee Affairs Bureau)
Disclaimer
Note: Legislative history and other information accessed from Congress Legis. Information as of April 20, 2022.